In a thrilling AFLW showdown, the Brisbane Lions roared to victory over the Melbourne Demons, securing their first-ever finals win against their rivals and booking a home preliminary final. But here's where it gets controversial... Was this a triumph of strategy, or did Melbourne's early setbacks seal their fate? Let’s dive in.
For the first time in AFLW history, Brisbane emerged victorious over Melbourne in a finals match, claiming a 9.2 (56) to 6.7 (43) win at Ikon Park. Both teams were desperate for a week off and a direct ticket to the preliminary final, but it was the Lions who ultimately prevailed, despite Melbourne’s strong start. And this is the part most people miss... Brisbane’s ability to shake off their recent scoring struggles was the game-changer, as they dominated the scoreboard when it mattered most.
The star of the show was Brisbane’s Ally Anderson, who delivered a commanding performance with 28 disposals, four clearances, and a career-best two goals. Her leadership on the field was undeniable, putting the Lions on her back when they needed it most. Meanwhile, Melbourne’s leading goalkicker, Eden Zanker, was ruled out early due to a head knock, despite passing her initial injury assessment. This left Tayla Harris and Georgia Gall to shoulder the load as the Demons’ primary marking targets near goal.
Early on, Melbourne’s defense was impeccable, shutting down Brisbane’s attempts to penetrate the corridor. Tahlia Gillard (11 intercepts, 17 disposals) was a defensive stalwart, while Eliza McNamara (27 disposals, 480 meters gained) worked tirelessly to support both attack and defense. Alyssa Bannan’s speed was also crucial in creating and closing down space. However, Brisbane eventually adapted, exploiting Melbourne’s defense with three quick goals within four minutes, all stemming from free kicks close to goal.
Melbourne’s Kate Hore was a standout, racking up 10 first-quarter disposals and forcing Brisbane’s Cathy Svarc to shadow her for the rest of the game. Hore’s 31 disposals and eight clearances were impressive, including her opening goal, which marked her 100-goal milestone. Yet, Brisbane’s balanced effort—led by Anderson, Svarc, Charlie Mullins (18 disposals, six clearances), and Belle Dawes (21 disposals, four clearances)—proved too much for the Demons to handle.
Here’s a bold question: Did Melbourne rely too heavily on Hore, or did Brisbane simply outmaneuver them? The Lions’ ability to move the ball with speed kept Melbourne’s backline under constant pressure, ultimately sealing their victory.
Looking ahead, Brisbane will use their week off to nurse All-Australian squad member Jennifer Dunne back to full fitness after a knee tweak. Meanwhile, Melbourne will host the winner of the Adelaide vs. St Kilda elimination final.
The curious case of Eden Zanker raises questions about concussion protocols. After an awkward collision, Zanker passed her SCAT but was later ruled out as a precaution, sparking debates about player safety versus game impact.
A horror patch for Saraid Taylor highlighted Melbourne’s vulnerabilities. In a five-minute span, Taylor’s errors gifted Brisbane two crucial goals, shifting the momentum decisively in the Lions’ favor.
Kate Hore’s 100-goal milestone was a bright spot for Melbourne, but the lack of fanfare underscored their focus on securing the win. Is it fair to say Hore’s achievement was overshadowed by the team’s loss?
As Brisbane prepares for their preliminary final, and Melbourne looks to regroup, one thing is clear: this match was a masterclass in resilience, strategy, and the fine line between victory and defeat. What’s your take? Did Brisbane deserve the win, or did Melbourne’s setbacks cost them the game? Let’s hear your thoughts in the comments!
